The AI honeymoon phase may be over, but that’s actually good news. Now, we have the opportunity to build mature, effective AI strategies that deliver on their intended ROI.
The artificial intelligence (AI) honeymoon phase is over. Across industries, enthusiasm for the technology is shifting from starry-eyed wonder to a reality check. We’ve officially entered the Trough of Disillusionment: a phase in the Gartner Hype Cycle where the initial excitement and inflated expectations are replaced by a more realistic (albeit often disappointing) assessment of a technology’s limitations, performance and failure to meet the promised ROI.
And while AI, particularly generative AI, has the potential to be transformative, the gap between cool demos and real-world success is widening, leaving many leaders scratching their heads. In fact, research shows that as many as 95% of genAI pilots fail to move beyond the experimental stage. So, where did it all go wrong? More importantly, how can leaders avoid falling for the hype and make smarter, lasting AI investments? It starts with identifying the red flags.
Red flag #1: Unrealistic timelines
If an AI vendor promises production-ready solutions in weeks, leaders should proceed with caution. While proofs of concept can be spun up quickly, scaling AI effectively and responsibly takes time. Data pipelines need to be cleaned, governance must be established and teams need to adapt workflows.
AI isn’t plug-and-play. Leaders should demand clear roadmaps that break down milestones across data preparation, testing, integration and adoption phases. Vendors who gloss over these steps may be overselling their capabilities. Time to value is only valuable if you can get your AI initiative off the ground.
Red flag #2: The ‘we’ll replace humans’ narrative
Vendors that tout AI as a complete replacement for human expertise often underestimate the nuance of real-world operations. While automation can streamline processes, most successful AI deployments rely on human-in-the-loop systems — whether for exception handling, oversight or ethical review.
Without a change-management plan or escalation path for human decision-makers, replace-humans narratives often collapse under the weight of organizational complexity. Leaders should press vendors on how human expertise fits into the AI workflow. Ask: “What happens when the system fails? Who takes over?” If there isn’t a thoughtful answer, consider it a red flag.
Red flag #3: Lack of integration with existing tech stacks
A common reason pilots stall is that AI tools don’t mesh with current infrastructure. It’s one thing to demo a chatbot or AI solution in isolation. It’s entirely different to integrate it with existing ERP systems, CRMs or cloud data platforms. A lack of integration creates data and organizational silos, operational inefficiencies and technical hurdles that undermine performance and, thus, business impact.
Leaders should insist on seeing integration plans up front. Successful vendors understand that adoption isn’t just about the AI; it’s about embedding AI into business-critical workflows. Prioritize centralizing data from across the business, creating a single source of truth, before scaling AI applications. You can also consider leveraging AI-ready platforms with built-in connectors and capabilities that simplify connecting legacy and modern systems.
Red flag #4: Ignoring prerequisites for success
AI thrives on strong foundations: the aforementioned centralized data, consistent governance and cross-functional alignment. Many failed pilots happen because organizations try to leapfrog into sophisticated AI before checking the prerequisites off this list. Downplaying this preparatory work is simply setting businesses up for frustration and, ultimately, failure.
Always assess your organizational readiness before investing. Ask your leaders:
- How will you modify workflows?
- Where will the new handoff points be?
- Will this shift quality standards and service-level expectations for customers?
- What tools will be introduced or reconfigured to support the new way of working?
- Are there any other hardware or software modifications needed beforehand?
If the answer is “I don’t know,” AI will only amplify existing inefficiencies rather than solve them.
Moving past the hype: The AI checklist
It’s not all bad news. Remember: After the Trough of Disillusionment comes the Slope of Enlightenment, where innovation benefits become clearer, leading to the Plateau of Productivity, where real-world value is proven. We’re on our way there and by spotting red flags, asking the right questions and preparing for change, leaders can get it right.
Here’s a brief AI checklist to ensure preparedness before embarking on your next AI project:
- Timelines: What are the milestones and how long will each phase realistically take?
- Human roles: How will our teams interact with the system? Where will workflows hand off from AI to team members and vice versa? What’s the escalation path?
- Integration: How does this fit with our existing tech stack? What APIs or connectors are supported?
- Readiness: What processes, governance and data structures need to be in place first?
- ROI: How will success be measured? Is there a clear path to value, not just experimentation?
The promise of AI is real, but so is the work required to unlock it. Leaders who recognize the common AI warning signs can avoid costly missteps and channel resources toward solutions that deliver measurable, lasting impact.
The AI honeymoon phase may be over, but that’s actually good news. Now, we have the opportunity to build mature, effective AI strategies that deliver on their intended ROI.
This article is published as part of the Foundry Expert Contributor Network.
Want to join?
